By OLUSOJI DAOMI
In Nigeria, truth does not always come dressed in fine grammar. Sometimes, it comes in a shout.
A cry in the night. A desperate call for help that neighbours hear before anyone understands what is happening. And sometimes… that cry becomes evidence.
Let us bring it home. Imagine a typical evening in a Nigerian compound. NEPA has just taken light. Generators are rumbling. Someone is frying akara by the roadside. Children are playing. Adults are exchanging gist across balconies. Suddenly, a voice tears through the air. “Chinedu! Please don’t stab me!” Before anyone can process it… chaos. A loud sound. Panic. People rush out. Doors open. Phones come out with torchlights. A man is found lying on the ground, bleeding. He struggles. He gasps. And before help can fully arrive, he dies.
Now fast forward to court. The neighbours gather as witnesses. One of them, Musa, steps forward. He did not see the fight. He did not see the knife. He only heard that voice. That desperate sentence. “Chinedu, please don’t stab me.”
The question then arises.
Can Musa’s testimony be used?
Can the court rely on words spoken by someone who is no longer alive?
Ordinarily, the law does not like such evidence. Nigerian law, under the Evidence Act, prefers direct evidence. It wants you to say, “I saw it with my eyes.” Anything else is treated as hearsay, and hearsay is usually rejected.
But there is an exception. A very powerful one.
It is called a dying declaration.
There is an old legal saying (nemo moriturus praesumitur mentiri), difficult in Latin but simple in meaning. It says that a person who is about to die is not expected to lie. The law assumes that when death is staring a person in the face, there is no reason to start telling lies or playing games.
At that moment, there is no benefit in deception. No future to protect. No image to manage.
Just truth… or what the person believes to be truth.
So when that dying man shouted “Chinedu, please don’t stab me,” the law may treat those words as evidence of who attacked him and how it happened.
Even though he is no longer alive to come to court.
Even though nobody saw the actual act.
His voice, in that moment, follows him into the courtroom.
But the law is not careless. It does not accept every last statement blindly. There are conditions.
The statement must be about what led to the person’s death. It cannot be about unrelated matters. If a man is dying and starts talking about land dispute in the village, that is not a dying declaration for a murder case. The words must connect directly to the incident.
The person must believe death is close. Not just fear. Not just injury. There must be that awareness that “this may be the end.” It is that seriousness that gives the statement weight.
The person must also be mentally aware. If someone is unconscious, confused, or not in control of their senses, the law will be careful. The words must come from a mind that understands what it is saying.
And in criminal cases, the person must actually die from the injury. That is why it is called a dying declaration. It is tied to death.
When these things come together, something powerful happens.
A man who cannot come to court… still speaks.
A voice from the scene… enters the courtroom.
A sentence shouted in fear… becomes evidence.
For many Nigerians, this is surprising. We are used to thinking that if nobody saw the act, then nothing can be proven. But the law is wiser than that. It understands human behaviour. It understands that in real life, crimes do not always happen in front of witnesses.
Sometimes, the only witness is the victim.
And sometimes, the victim speaks just once… before dying.
That one statement can carry weight. It can influence the judge. It can support other evidence. In some cases, it can be the turning point.
But there is also a lesson beyond the law.
Life has moments when people speak without filters. No planning. No lies. No strategy. Just raw truth.
The law recognises that moment.
That is why it does not ignore the last words of a dying person.
Not every case needs ten eyewitnesses.
Not every truth is seen with the eyes.
Sometimes, it is heard.
That shout in the night.
That cry for help.
That name mentioned in fear.
The law does not throw it away.
It listens. Carefully. Seriously.
Because sometimes, the most powerful evidence is not what was seen in daylight… but what was said in the final moments before darkness.
READ ALSO:
ADC: INEC removes David Mark-led NWC from portal
Gains of IGP Disu’s bold tactical team reform, By Femi Malik
Jurisdiction of the Federal High Courts under the 1999 Constitution
No police officer has right to board vehicles without paying -AIG
FAAN diverts flights at MMIA due to electric spark
Tinubu postpones Ogun trip, heads to Jos over killings
Suspected chemical odour leaves 31 hospitalised in Ogun school
Middle-East crisis: How Tinubu’s policy of naira-for-crude guarantees supply security in Nigeria
