By OLUSOJI DAOMI
A man wakes up, picks up his phone and discovers that somebody has posted his photograph with the caption: “This man is a fraudster. He collected my money and disappeared.” Within minutes, the post is circulating across WhatsApp groups, Facebook, Instagram and X. People begin to insult him. Others call for his arrest. Some publish his telephone number and home address. Before the day ends, the matter has moved from social media to the police station.
But there is a question both parties should ask: was this a legitimate complaint, an irresponsible publication, an act of defamation or a criminal cybercrime? Welcome to the increasingly complicated relationship between social media, freedom of expression and the law in Nigeria.
Social media has given ordinary Nigerians a voice that previous generations could hardly imagine. A trader can expose an alleged fraudulent transaction. A consumer can complain about a defective product. A journalist can investigate public corruption. A citizen can criticise a government policy without waiting for a newspaper editor to give him space. This is the beauty of freedom of expression.
But freedom is not the same as lawlessness. Your Facebook account is not a courtroom, your WhatsApp status is not a police investigation, and the number of likes under your post does not turn an allegation into an established fact.
The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999, as amended, guarantees freedom of expression under section 39. It protects the right to hold opinions and to receive and impart ideas and information. However, that right does not automatically excuse unlawful conduct, including defamatory publications or communications that satisfy the ingredients of a criminal offence. The challenge is to protect free speech without allowing the internet to become a marketplace for character assassination.
This brings us to the Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015, as amended in 2024. One of its most controversial provisions is section 24, which deals with certain communications transmitted through computer systems or networks.
Before the 2024 amendment, section 24(1) contained broad expressions relating to offensive and false messages, including messages intended to cause annoyance, insult, hatred, ill will or needless anxiety. These expressions generated serious concerns about the possible use of the law against journalists, activists and ordinary citizens who criticised powerful individuals.
The National Assembly subsequently amended the provision. Under the amended section 24(1), a person who knowingly or intentionally sends a message or other matter through a computer system or network commits an offence where the message is pornographic, or where the sender knows it to be false and sends it for the purpose of causing a breakdown of law and order or posing a threat to life. The penalty under that subsection is a fine of up to ₦7 million, imprisonment for up to three years, or both.
Notice the difference. The mere fact that a statement is unpleasant, embarrassing or critical does not automatically establish the offence under the amended section 24(1). The prosecution must establish the relevant statutory ingredients, including the required knowledge and purpose in the case of a knowingly false message. A person who publishes a genuine criticism of public conduct should not automatically be treated as a cybercriminal simply because the subject of the criticism is offended.
Section 24(2), however, remains important. It addresses communications knowingly or intentionally transmitted to bully, threaten or harass another person where the communication places that person in fear of death, violence or bodily harm. It also addresses specified threats involving kidnapping, harm and extortion. The law therefore distinguishes between ordinary disagreement and communications involving serious threats, intimidation or conduct falling within the statutory provisions.
Now let us examine another issue Nigerians frequently misunderstand: the difference between civil defamation and criminal liability. Suppose a businesswoman publishes on Facebook that a named trader is a thief who routinely defrauds customers. The trader says the allegation is false and that his reputation has been damaged. He may institute a civil action for defamation, subject to the applicable law and the facts. If successful, the court may award damages and grant other appropriate remedies.
In Guardian Newspapers Ltd. v. Ajeh (2011) 10 NWLR (Pt. 1256) 574, the Supreme Court considered the principles governing libel and emphasised the essential ingredients of the tort. Generally, a claimant must establish that the words were defamatory, that they referred to the claimant and that they were published to a third party. The particular form of defamation, the circumstances and the applicable defences must also be considered.
Civil defamation is not the same thing as cyberstalking. A person who alleges that a social media publication damaged their reputation does not automatically establish a criminal offence under section 24 of the Cybercrimes Act. The police must investigate an actual suspected offence under the law; they should not simply convert every disagreement, debt dispute, reputational complaint or criticism into a cybercrime allegation.
Can criminal defamation exist in Nigeria? Yes, criminal defamation provisions also exist under applicable criminal legislation, including the Criminal Code and Penal Code regimes, depending on the jurisdiction. But the mere fact that a publication is alleged to be defamatory does not automatically make it an offence under section 24 of the Cybercrimes Act. The precise offence, its statutory ingredients and the applicable jurisdiction must be identified.
There is also the important defence of truth, commonly called justification. If you publish an allegation that a person stole money, committed fraud or engaged in some other dishonest conduct, and that person sues you for defamation, can you simply tell the court, “But everybody knows it is true”?
No. The court requires evidence, not social media consensus. In Onwurah & Ors. v. Nwumeh & Anor. (2016) LCN/8464(CA), the Court of Appeal explained that a defendant relying on justification must establish the truth of the defamatory publication by evidence. The truth must be substantial; it is not enough to repeat an allegation or rely on rumours. The standard of proof for the defence is the balance of probabilities. In practical terms, the defendant must produce credible evidence showing that the substance of the allegation is true.
For example, if you accuse somebody of collecting ₦5 million from you under a contract and refusing to refund it, preserve the agreement, receipts, bank transfer records, correspondence and other relevant evidence. But be careful: a person who owes you money is not automatically a fraudster. A breach of contract and the criminal offence of obtaining money by false pretence are not the same thing. The facts and evidence must support the particular allegation you make.
The National Human Rights Commission recognised the danger of confusing legitimate expression with cybercrime. In its Advisory on the Protection of the Right to Freedom of Expression in Nigeria, dated 4 April 2025, the Commission specifically addressed the application of section 24 of the amended Cybercrimes Act to law enforcement agencies, the judiciary, journalists, bloggers, influencers and ordinary social media users. It emphasised that freedom of expression includes political discourse, comments on public affairs and the right to criticise government policies and actions. That advisory is an important reminder that law enforcement must apply the provision consistently with constitutional rights.
So, what should Nigerians do before publishing that explosive post? Do not publish an allegation simply because somebody sent it to your WhatsApp. Verify it. Preserve evidence. Distinguish between what you personally know, what you suspect and what somebody else has told you. If you are reporting a dispute, describe the facts accurately rather than declaring someone guilty of a crime before investigation or trial. Avoid threats, harassment, the publication of private information for intimidation, and calls for violence. If you have been wronged, seek lawful remedies rather than turning social media into an instrument of revenge.
Equally, if you are the subject of a defamatory or threatening publication, preserve screenshots, links, dates, usernames and other available evidence. Do not respond with threats or counter-allegations. Seek legal advice on whether the appropriate remedy is a civil action, a criminal complaint or a complaint under the Cybercrimes Act. The correct legal route depends on the facts.
The internet has made publication easy, but it has not abolished responsibility. A person who presses the share button may be contributing to the publication of an allegation. A person who repeats an unverified accusation may expose himself or herself to legal consequences. And a person who uses the threat of police arrest to silence every critic should equally understand that constitutional freedom of expression is not a favour granted by powerful individuals.
The law protects your right to speak, but it does not give you the right to lie, threaten or destroy another person’s reputation with impunity. Equally, nobody should use the police or the Cybercrimes Act to turn legitimate criticism into a crime.
In a democracy, citizens must be free to speak, but they must also be responsible for what they say. The right to speak is precious; the duty to speak responsibly is equally important.
Before you post, ask yourself one question: if I am required to defend these words in court tomorrow, do I have the evidence to support them?
READ ALSO:
Military airstrikes neutralise 21 ISWAP fighters in Borno
Tinubu approves University of Public Relations and Leadership
Ebomhe to head NFF normalisation committee
THE ranking: Covenant University leads Africa again
Tinubu receives State Police bill after 36 states’ approval
2027: Yayi realised his looming defeat the day Adebutu returned to the ballot -PDP
Realnews lecture: Minister confirms attendance as special guest of honour
Senate directs NASS Clerk to transmit state police bill to Tinubu
Five arrested over alleged killing of BEDC worker in Delta
Alleged fake agency: ICPC re-arraigns Adeyemi, four civil servants
EXTRA: When the shutter fell silent, By Kunle Azeez
The digital anointing: Jimi Odukoya, the algorithm, and the church of the comment section



